Better watch out if you are a Board Member in your HOA Making All the Decisions

Better watch out if you are a Board Member in your HOA Making All the Decisions.

The courts of California have rendered a decision at the appellate level (which makes the decision binding law) that allows a court to look past the business judgment rule to see whether any diligent investigation or vetting of options and discussion with board members was done by a Board President before signing contracts. The contracts went south. The contractors sought damages, and now the Association is looking at whether it can extract some damages from the Board President. The Board President’s legal counsel is seeking review by the California Supreme Court asking that it turn over the decision that allows a judge to look past the Business Judgment rule when the director argues he or she was acting in good faith. The allegation challenging the good faith aspect is that the director did not make reasonable inquiry about the contractors, did not seek the advice of proper experts, and ignored the governing documents regarding requirements for construction contracts and procuring loans.

If you want to follow my own writings about this case, watch the blogs and sign up for the E-newsletter. The very next one will be on this most important case and how board member conduct (or should I say misconduct) can lead to individual director liability, whether you are the do-er or the directors who sit by and let the do-er run unchecked.


This topic is BIG. You can also come to a live discussion of this and other very hot topics, coming soon at the South Coast Homeowners Association program on October 13, 7-9. Visit their site to join. It’s a great resource. Here is the notice for the Program:


PALM SPRINGS VILLAS II BID FOR SUPREME COURT REVIEW. This CASE is added because of an existing court decision that is the subject of a request for review by the highest court in California. Granted or not, this case will establish some important law in the state. It will speak to the question of whether an individual board member can be held responsible for any losses that an association suffers because of bad decisions. The Board President on the hot seat is an 87 year old woman who signed construction contracts allegedly without investigation of contractor licenses and without board approval, and signed loan documents without a vote of the members and may be put to the task of “proving” diligence. The HOA was sued by a contractor for breach of contract. The Association has sued the individual board member seeking judgment. At stake in California is the future of the protections afforded by the Business Judgment Rule, Directors and Officers Liability insurance options, and the pros and cons of board service.  It’s way too hot to not talk about!!


REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE PROBLEMS? Are you dealing with any maintenance, repair and replacement questions or disputes in your HOA or Condo Association? Are you confused by AB 968 and the law (before, now and after January 1, 2017) relating to responsibility for exclusive use common area maintenance and repair? Are you concerned or confused about who fixes windows, doors, balconies (flooring, railings, joists, privacy walls, enclosures, etc.), stoops, planters, painting, siding, roof covering vs. the structural parts of the roofs, roof decks, washers, dryers, leaks from roofs, washers and dryers?


RENTAL LIMITATIONS? What about short term rentals and limiting rentals? What are the pros and the pitfalls?  And which controls, the law or your documents? Can you ban Air BnB rentals altogether or cash in on fees that are similar to the local “taxes” and fines being imposed by municipalities throughout the state?


Come to this session and Beth Grimm will try to give you some simple strategies for dealing with and heading off the problems in these areas. She will do her best to keep you awake (this is an evening program for a change) offering strategies to avoid horror stories in these areas. You may need help just deciding whether policy-making can alleviate the problem, or you need an overhaul of your governing documents (meaning amendments or updates).


Beth says she is looking forward to coming to Goleta, as usual, to share a few hours with you brainstorming solutions to HOA and Condo quandaries.


Date – Thursday, October 13

Time –  7-9 PM (refreshments at 6:45)

Place – Encina Royale Clubhouse – 250 Moreton Bay Lane, Goleta





I have been a condo-homeowners association attorney for more than 24 years. I like helping people get their arms around their homeowner association problems and find a solution. A balanced attitude can go further to resolve issues than just about anything else.

Related Articles

Can an HOA Draft Their Own CC&Rs and Do A good Job?

Lots of times I get asked if the association can save money on the amendment and restatement of governing documents

How Do You Find A Homeowners Association?

I got a call today from a realtor, a common occurrence, asking for an association’s contact information. The buyer wanted

How Do You Prevent A Petition for Recall?

I have seen a lot of recall petitions – here are some of the things I see that lead to

No comments

Write a comment
No Comments Yet! You can be first to comment this post!

Write a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published.
Required fields are marked*