Appeals Court Reverses Big Smoking Verdict Against Co-op (NY)

A year ago, state Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron sent shivers through New York City’s co-op community when he ruled that Susan Reinhard, a shareholder at the Connaught Tower co-op at 300 East 54 Street, was entitled to $120,000 in back maintenance, interest, and attorney’s fees after she claimed secondhand smoke had permeated her apartment and rendered it uninhabitable.  Last week, the Supreme Court’s Appellate Division, First Department, overturned that verdict – even ruling that Reinhard is now on the hook not only for her back maintenance, but also for the co-op’s attorney’s fees. “In particular,” the court wrote, “(Reinhard) failed to show that the (smoke) odor was present on a consistent basis and that it was sufficiently pervasive as to affect the health and safety of occupants.”     Read the article…………..


Related Articles

Representatives Israel and Nadler (NY) make progress on disaster relief in community associations

In the aftermath of Super Storm Sandy, Rep. Steve Israel (D-NY) and Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-NY) took on key leadership

HOA’s members need not testify about their own side’s strategy meetings (CA)

Lawyers for organizations may feel both shudders and relief on reading a recent appellate decision protecting attorney-client privilege for the

Homeowner Associations: $1,180,646.50 Fee/$27,730 Costs Award Against HOA Owners And In Favor Of HOA Affirmed On Appeal

This next case is somewhat frightening for all litigants and practitioners—no matter what substantive areas you practice in. It does